Christian MP's torn on airstrikes vote

Christian MPs are torn on whether to support British air strikes against ISIS in Syria.


The Government published a motion this afternoon (Tuesday) and MPs will be asked to vote tomorrow evening. The twelve-point plan, approved by the cabinet this morning, says ISIS poses a "direct threat" to the UK and insists there is a legal basis for action.

Around 10pm tomorrow night, MPs will be asked to support "her majesty's government in taking military action, specifically airstrikes, exclusively against ISIL in Syria." 

Prime Minister David Cameron will ask the Commons tomorrow to back military action on Syria.

The majority of Conservatives will support air strikes and the majority of Labour are expected to oppose. However considerable rebellions, particularly among Labour MPs may tilt the vote in favour of supporting air strikes. The Liberal Democrats, led by Tim Farron, have said there are "ongoing discussions" and have not decided how they will vote. Similarly the SNP have been unclear although it is expected they will oppose.

However it seems that Christian MPs are split on the issue.

Gavin Shuker and David Lammy, two Christian Labour MPs have been vocal in their opposition of air strikes.

David Lammy
David Lammy MP for Tottenham

Lammy, the MP for Tottenham said he is not "an instinctive ideologue or a pacifist" but did not think he had heard a "compelling case" for military action. In a statement he argued "there is a worrying lack of strategy" after military intervention and said "air strikes will harm civilians and could serve as a key recruitment tool for ISIS."

Ultimately, he said, "military strikes will deepen the power vacuum in Syria that has allowed ISIS to spread its hateful ideology."

Lammy received support from his fellow Christian Labour MP, Gavin Shuker, who said he "cannot envisage a circumstance in which I would support military action in Syria."

Ben Bradshaw MP for Exeter
Ben Bradshaw, the Labour MP for Exeter

However Ben Bradshaw, the Labour MP for Exeter, also a Christian, has said he is leaning towards supporting "the RAF extending its existing action against Daesh (ISIS) to Syria."

Although Bradshaw had not confirmed his voting intention at the time of writing it is likely he will vote in favour of air strikes and be one of up to 50 Labour MPs expected to go against Jeremy Corbyn's wishes.

Bradshaw argued that "Daesh (ISIS) are a real and present threat to Britain" and the failure to intervene militarily in Syria "has led to the worst humanitarian and refugee crisis since World War Two, with half the Syrian population killed or displaced."

Christians in the Conservative party are equally split. Renowned rebel and Roman Catholic Stephen McPartland, the Tory MP for Stevenage has vowed to "vote against military action in Syria."

"No one is winning and millions of innocent civilians in Syria are suffering, our efforts should be focused on reconciliation rather than firing a few missiles to salve international consciences," he said on his website.

But Jeremy Lefroy, the Conservative MP for Stafford has he "very much supports" the Prime Minister's plan to extend British air strikes against ISIS into Syria.

David Burrowes, another outspoken Christian in the Tory party also voiced his support and has said he agrees with David Cameron's position.

The divide of opinion among Christian MP reflects contrasting opinions in the church. The Church of England's synod unanimously passed a motion which implied support for military action with Justin Welby adding that armed conflict was "almost inevitable" to defeat ISIS.

However the archbishop of the Church of Wales, which is separate from the Church of England but part of the Anglican Communion, has urged MPs to oppose the motion and warned there is "no moral case for bombing Syria."

"It is obvious," he said, "that even on a just war argument, a clear moral case for bombing Syria cannot be advanced."

However many MPs remain undecided and will spend tonight making their decision. Fiona Bruce, the Conservative MP for Congleton refused to commit either way but said "safety and security" of her constituents remained her primary concern. 

"I believe it is important I most carefully listen to and consider all the arguments and views on this issue, including those from my constituents, and this I am doing in the run up to this vote," she she is reported as saying.

As MPs of all religious and political persuasions consider their decision this evening, hundreds of protesters have gathered outside the Labour HQ and Conservative HQ to demonstrate against the strikes.

"Bombs are not the solution, they are the problem," one protester said. "I don't think it is a very practical approach."

Do you have an opionon? What are your thoughts?  Add your response below:

The Government published a motion this afternoon (Tuesday) and MPs will be asked to vote tomorrow evening.

Heart 4 Ipswich, 01/12/2015
QueenBDayJune2016 236x136
The Servant Queen and the King She serves
Bible Society, HOPE and LICC, have produced a very special 64-page book The Servant Queen and the King She Serves, to help churches and schools to mark this milestone in the life of the nation More ...
Heart 4 Ipswich
Queen 236 136
Ipswich Churches to Celebrate Royally in June
In June the nation and Commonwealth will celebrate the Queen's 90th birthday. Just like the Diamond Jubilee celebrations in 2012, Ipswich churches will be celebrating in the communities together. Time to Party!! More ...
Heart 4 Ipswich
brussels attacks 236x136
Brussels Bombing: Suffolk Bishop joins prayers
Rt Revd Martin Seeley joined Christians in Brussels and around the world to pray as Belgian Prime Minister Charles Michel confirms over 31 people have been killed and hundreds injured More ...
Heart 4 Ipswich
Real Easter Egg 2016 236x136
Get the Egg that shares the Easter story
This year The Real Easter Egg range has had a makeover and each single boxed egg includes a unique copy of the Easter story in the shape of a pull out 37 cm high cross. Order yours now or pick one up from Ipswich CLC Bookshop More ...
Heart 4 Ipswich
Queen 236 136
ChurchCare launches resource for Queen's 90th
A central news sharing resource for churches and cathedrals has been launched to encourage and equip communities as they organise celebrations to mark Her Majesty The Queen’s 90th birthday in June 2016. More ...
Heart 4 Ipswich
AMITM Thmb
Alternative Man on the Moon Advert
The much anticipated Christmas advert for St Thomas' church in Norwich was aired for the first time, as a follow-up to last year's award-winning video inspired by the John Lewis Christmas advert. More ...
Heart 4 Ipswich
Rwandan refugee camp thumbnail
Please Pray for Burundi
Paul and Jean Daltry, Christian leaders in Ipswich, ask for your prayers for Burundi. They lived and worked in Rwanda for six years prior to the genocide there and have seen the horrors that can happen to a country when it seems as if God departs. More ...
Heart 4 Ipswich
Home for Good Video
Sunday 1st November is Adoption Sunday
In the UK, 4,000 children are waiting for adoption and 8,600 foster families are desperately needed. The national Christian charity 'Home for Good' believe that the Church can make a difference. More ...
Heart 4 Ipswich
church photo
Hate Crime, Love the Criminal
They gathered in the church to read the Bible and pray. How could they have known that the young man who joined them that day was carrying a weapon? And although they offered him hospitality, Dylann Roof responded by shooting them dead. More ...
Richard Collins, LICC
nepal3
Latest Update on Nepal Earthquake Appeal
Latest Update: (28-Apr-2015) Christian Aid supporters are responding quickly and generously to the plight of victims of the Nepal earthquake following the launch of an appeal on Saturday evening. More ...
Heart 4 Ipswich
C A logo2
Nepal Earthquake Appeal
Christian Aid has launched an emergency appeal to provide urgent aid in the wake of the Nepal earthquake disaster and it has been backed by the charity’s East Anglia regional co-ordinator. Christian Aid are already providing urgent relief to victims More ...
Heart 4 Ipswich

To submit a story or publicise an event please email:  stories@heart4ipswich.co.uk